Pony Island vs Undertale
Which one is worth buying now, with today's prices and each game's recommendation.
Undertale wins 11 of 15 head-to-head metrics. Undertale is $1.65 cheaper.
Metric by metric
The winner of each row gets a ✓. No row weighs more than another; the recommendation is calculated separately.
| Metric | Pony Island | Undertale |
|---|---|---|
| GameValio scoreRecommendation: Maybe × Worth It | 68 | 77 |
| Quality | 92 | 96 |
| Value | 59 | 70 |
| Popularity | 34 | 45 |
| Current Best Price (USD) | $4.14 | $2.49 |
| Steam Review Score | 95% positive | 96.6% positive |
| Average Concurrent Players (14 days) | 532 | 1.4K |
Where to buy
The 3 cheapest stores for each game
Side by side over time
Pony IslandUndertale
Details and requirements
| Item | Pony Island | Undertale |
|---|---|---|
| Release date | January 4, 2016 | September 15, 2015 |
| Developers | Daniel Mullins Games | tobyfox |
| Publishers | Daniel Mullins Games | tobyfox |
| Platforms | Linux, Windows, MacOs | Linux, Windows, MacOs |
| OS (minimum) | Windows Vista / 7 / 8 / 10 | Windows XP, Vista, 7, or 10 |
| Memory (minimum) | 4 GB RAM | 3 GB RAM |
| DirectX (minimum) | Version 9.0 | — |
| Storage (minimum) | 400 MB available space | 200 MB available space |
| Processor (minimum) | — | 2GHz+ |
| Graphics (minimum) | — | 512MB |
Frequently asked questions
Which is better: Pony Island or Undertale?
Undertale won the comparison against Pony Island based on the head-to-head metric breakdown. Check the metrics table above for a full side-by-side analysis.
How is the comparison calculated?
The comparison winner is determined objectively by counting which game wins more individual metrics in the head-to-head table. No weighting is applied. The GameValio Recommendation shown separately is our own suggestion for each game, based on a weighted score that combines quality (reviews), popularity (player counts), and affordability (price vs value) into a score out of 100. These are two different things: the comparison is objective, the recommendation is GameValio's opinion.
Is Pony Island worth buying over Undertale?
Based on the metrics, Undertale won the direct comparison. However, also check the GameValio Recommendation for each game and the price comparison table to make the most informed purchase decision.
Which game has better player reviews?
Review score trends and volume over time are shown in the charts section above. The game with consistently higher positive ratios has stronger community reception.
Which game offers better value for money?
The affordability score and price comparison table above highlight the best deals. Undertale currently scores better on value relative to its quality and price.
Related comparisons
Analysis updated: Oct 24, 2026, 12:58 PM UTC